Religion is defined as \"the belief in and worship of a superhuman
controlling power, especially a personal God\" . There are many recognised
religions of the world, which all teach its followers to live life \"the right
way\", whose definition varies according to the religion itself. They have some
beliefs and practices that distinguish themselves from each other. Some examples
are differences and similarities of Buddhism and Islam.
Buddhism
originated from India, and was founded by Prince Siddharta Gautama, who later
came to be known as Buddha, or the enlightened one. Born of a princely caste, he
later renounced his comfortable life in search for nirvana. In order to do that,
he joined a band of ascetic, who was a group of Hindu priests. In his teaching,
the Buddha taught his followers to follow \"the middle way\", that is, not the
way of extreme asceticism. He attained full understanding of the nature of being
by meditation and after his success, decided to impart his knowledge to those
who follow him .
Islam, on the other hand, started in Mecca, where
Prophet Muhammad was born. He was believed to be that last nabi (messenger) that Allah will give to the world. The religion was not well
accepted in its city of origin though, due to the opposition the Prophet faced
as a nascent community . Later, he was invited to Medina and Islam expanded from
there.
Both these religions have basic beliefs that are relatively
different from each other. Buddhists on one hand believe in karma, rebirth,
dharma and moksa. Karma is \"cause, effect and the law which equilibrates the
two\" . It is the consequences of every action, whether good or bad. This
action-reaction may take effect anytime, may be in the current life or not.
Rebirth is inter-connected with karma. If one did more good things than bad in
his life, his karma will lead him to a life of better condition than the
previous one. Dharma is the basic concept of the religion; that is the Buddhist
teaching, also meaning the nature of existence. Lastly, moksa refers to the
renunciation of the world, which is parallel to the Hindu belief in the
importance of asceticism and meditation .
In addition, Buddhism
places emphasis on the Four Noble Truths, which is the teaching of Buddha, a
guide to enlightenment. These are a set of guidance that basically teaches the
followers of Buddha the essence of life; that life is basically suffering if it
is lived typically, and that the cause of suffering is desire. It discloses the
way to cure desires. The Fourth Noble Truth specifically talks about how it can
be accomplished through the Eightfold path.
The Eightfold path is the
treatment to cure all desires of the heart. Briefly, they are having the right
attitudes towards life, in a Buddhist way. It consists of having the Right
Knowledge, Right Aspiration, Right Speech, Right Behaviour, Right Livelihood,
Right Effort, Right Mindfulness and Right Absorption. It is taught that Buddhism
\"is a way of living, not merely the theory of life, the treading of this Path
is essential to self-deliverance\" .
On the other hand, Islam\'s basic
rules of conduct consist of five commandments. These are shahada, which is the
most fundamental of the commandments - the declaration of belief that there is
only one God, and Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is His messenger. Shalat, which is
praying five times a day to reaffirm submission to God, Saum -- fasting in the
month of Ramadan which requires abstinence from everything worldly. All Muslims
are required give 2.5% of his savings to charity, and this is termed Zakat. It
is considered a social welfare responsibility and Hajj, which is going for
pilgrimage after the end of Ramadan .
From these, it can be noted that
the beliefs and practices of the two religions is considerably different.
Firstly, Allah in the Islamic belief exists as a supernatural being, a God in a
monotheistic religion, whereas Buddha initially existed as a man and attained
nirvana through meditation. In addition, Buddhism is a pantheistic religion, but
later schools with theistic beliefs developed. In relation to this belief is the
practice of prayer that Muslims place importance on, but the Buddhists
disregard, and rather believe in meditation or the cleansing of mind.
The second major difference is the incentive for not doing evil in life.
For a Buddhist, the reason why one does not harm other beings, for example, is
that it will affect your karma. For a Muslim, it is more of because Allah will
punish bad deeds and reward good ones. The ultimate goal in both religions also
differ, Muslims\' are to go to heaven, whereas Buddhists\' are to attain
nirvana. The Buddha also said that the human self has no atta (soul) in contrary
to Muslims.
The roles of scriptures in the two religions also differ.
Muslims treat the Koran as the literal word of Allah. It is believed to have
been passed down to Muhammad over twenty-three years in the form of Gabriel\'s
(Allah\'s angel) voice . It is from this Koran that a Muslim understands his
Allah\'s commandments. In contrast, Buddha does not have a holy book that plays
such a big role in the religion. The most important scripture for a Buddhist is
the Tripitaka. It originally consists of three volumes of teaching, but its role
is not as significant as in the case of Islam. Initially, the Buddha passed down
his knowledge to his followers verbally, and his followers memorised them.
Eventually, the Tripitaka was put together, and overtime, other additional
scriptures and poems were added to it .
It is also partly due to the
differences in interpreting the Tripitaka that Buddhism spread into two major
schools, Theravada and Mahayana (some consider Zen Buddhism or Vajrayana to also
be major schools). The school of Theravada, which is translated as \"the Way of
the Elders\", believes that the importance of Buddhism in oneself, that is
focusing on attaining nirvana. Mahayana Buddhism, on the other hand is more of
\"a layperson Buddhism\" . It focuses on compassion and kindness, noting that
the Buddha himself forgoes nirvana in order to help others attain it. There are
many other reasons why Buddhism split, but most is the different perceptions and
thinking of the Buddha\'s followers. As the religion grow older and its
followers increase, different schools start to appear and some practices altered
. Buddhism in China, for example, diverge into the country\'s thick cultural
roots and emerged as a belief that is essentially different from the original
one; that is beliefs in spirits (animism) and ancestor worship (Confucianism).
Similar to Buddhism, Islam also had a split in its believers. However,
contrary to it, the split in the Islamic religion is not mainly due to
perceptions of the scriptures but rather due to the contest whether his heir
should become the Khalifah after Muhammad\'s death, as by Arab\'s patriarchal
inheritance system. Some argued that Islam should not follow the Arabic system
and that Islam should be handed down to a Muslim of a good piety . Intense
arguments broke into the assassination of one of the claimants of the position .
It is for mainly this reason that the believers are divided into two groups, the
Shi\'ites, Sufis and the Sunnis. Later, deviations of Islam occur again to
expose unorthodox schools such as the \"Black Muslim Movement\" .
Another similar but yet different aspect of Buddhism and Islam is the
way these two religions have abstinence towards some of the food they consume.
However, the reason why they do so differs. Some Buddhists become vegetarian in
an attempt to adhere to the Eightfold path, one of which is \"to kill no living
things\" . Muslim on the other hand, can only consume food that is considered
halal. Food that is considered not halal includes pork, and other animals that
are not slaughtered the specific way . Fasting from dawn to dusk for a Muslims
is a necessity during the month of Ramadan. For Buddhists, fasting is advised as
meditation , which goal is to purify the mind and body.
The role of
women in Buddhism and Islam also differs. Buddha is known to refuse his
stepmother into the Order, and he was reported to say that the admittance of
them would only \"shorten the life of Buddhist religion\" . The Koran, however,
stated that men and women are equal in the eyes of Allah, although in practice
it is not necessarily so .
These are some of the major differences and
similarities in Buddhism and Islam. However, the main similarity of them all is
the process of attaining the ultimate goal; that it moulds the character of the
person. By persevering to any religion, one is shaped to become a better
persona, which is the aim of any religion.
Reference List
Castro J.
(ed. Director) 1999-2000 (copyright), Buddhism. Hp. Online. Britannica.com Inc.
Available: http://www.britannica.com/bcom/eb/article/0/0,5716,108288+1,00.html.
19 May 2000.
Castro J. (ed. Director) 1999-2000 (copyright), Islam. Hp.
Online. Britannica.com Inc. Available:
http://www.britannica.com/bcom/eb/article/8/0,5716,108138+1,00.html. 19 May
2000.
Donath D.C. 1974, Buddhism for the West, McGraw-Hill Paperbacks,
United States of America.
Dr. Patrick Jory 2000, Out of India II:
Buddhism and its Continuing Appeal (lecture 10), University of Western
Australia, Perth.
Dr. Yasmeen S. 2000, Islam in the International
Relations, University of Western Australia, Perth.
Esposito J.L. 1991,
Islam, the Straight Path, Oxford University Press, New York
Humphreys C.
1951, Buddhism, Penguin Books, Middlesex, England.
Nigosian S. 1987,
Islam: The Way of Submission, London, Crucible, pp. 21-27, 153-172.
Pearsall, J. (ed) 1999, The Concise Oxford Dictionary, Oxford University
Press, New York, p. 1209.
Rippin A. 1990, Muslims, Their Religious
Beliefs and Practices Volume 1: The Formative Period, Routledge, London and New
York.
.
Robinson B.A. 1 Mar 2000 (last update), Islam, Hp. Online.
Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance. Available:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/islam.htm. 19 May 2000.
Robinson
B.A. 29 Mar 2000 (last update), Buddhism, Hp. Online. Ontario Consultants on
Religious Tolerance. Available:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/buddhism.htm. 19 May 2000.
Smith
H. 1991, The World\'s Religions, San Francisco, Harper, pp. 231-235.
Smith H. 1994, The Illustrated World religion, San Francisco, Harper,
pp. 70-85.
Tritton A.S. 1966, Islam, Hutchinson University Library,
London.